EDUCATION IS A BATTLEGROUND. GOOD TEACHERS ARE WARRIORS. THESE ARE THE FRONTLINES.
Home   Columns   Commentaries   Graduate Students
Curriculum Vitae
  Speeches   Publications  
China
 

KS School Naturalist

Contact
 
Don't Penalize People
Who Aren't "Online" 
Listen to the
commentary at:
Listen at KPR

Aired February 4, 2010 during "Morning Edition"

Want to know your child’s lunch options? Go online.
 
Constant updates are now available on your child’s academic progress. But only online.
 
Your check gets deposited directly. Want to know your deductions? Go online.
 
And now, when you file taxes, you need to file online?
 
There is an assumption—a terribly wrong assumption—that everyone has, or soon will have, computers connecting them to the internet at work and at home.
 
According to a direct marketing trade publication, after many years of increasing internet access, the percentage of households with internet connections peaked in 2006 and has gone down for the last three years in a row. This is due to the economic downturn, of course.
 
Add together the monthly cost of a broadband internet connection, perhaps an extra phone line, and the initial cost of buying the computer and hookup and peripherals (divided by the 3-5 year life of this rapidly-obsolete equipment) and each household is paying close to a thousand dollars a year to be part of the online generation. More and more households can no longer afford it.
 
Direct marketers are recognizing this downturn.
 
Online advertising has not been as effective as originally touted.
 
While there has been an a decline in all advertising formats, the percentage using printed direct mail is now going up.
Your mailbox is again filling up with junk mail.
 
But government, business and education entities remain mesmerized by the computer-industrial complex into thinking that every American is going to be online in just a few more years. Most colleges and universities no longer publish catalogs or schedules.
 
From one-fourth to one-third of rural Kansas students are without internet at home and have to go to schools or public libraries to get online. Non-traditional students, the unemployed, the elderly, and the rural isolated have become "non-persons."
 
It is true that to get around in America takes a car. And folks who do not have a car are handicapped in finding work and getting around. But we don’t require you by law to have a car, and charge you a penalty for not having one. But that may be the direction we are headed.
 
Unlike driving, you are required to file taxes.
 
Sure, it is more costly for the state to process a paper tax return than one filed electronically. But that newfound state economy was bought by many Kansans paying far more for their electronics and connections.
 
Those of us with computers admittedly use them for more than paying taxes.
 
But our behavior should not penalize those who cannot afford this expensive medium...or chose not to use it.
 
Futurists who dream of every newborn baby being connected to the internet need to write science fiction stories, not state policies. They also need to get out a little more, and see that there are a lot of people in Kansas who are not online—folks who actually have a life not tied to a computer screen.
 
"Life, liberty, and the possession of a computer..."
That is not in the Declaration of Independence.


 
  Home | Columns | Commentaries | Contact  
  © 2009-2011 John Richard Schrock